W/WW Project Delivery Selection Matrix

photo

Objective

The Design Build Institute of America Rocky Mountain Region (DBIA RMR) Water/Wastewater Committee found a growing need to identify which project delivery method should be used on water and wastewater construction projects. The idea stemmed the belief that each owner and project is unique and there is no one-size-fits-all delivery method. The goal of DBIA RMR Water/Wastewater Committee was to develop a project delivery selection matrix (PDSM) for owners to use when selecting between design-bid-build, construction management at risk and design-build delivery methods. The outcome of the PDSM is an objective project delivery selection report that documents this key decision and communicates it to the project stakeholders.

Tools

The DBIA RMR Water/Wastewater Committee, with the help of a research team from the University of Colorado Boulder, has developed two versions of the selection tool; one which can be used to facilitate a ½ day workshop with key team members and one that can be done in a few hours with one or more decision-makers. Before using either of these tools, please download and read the background documents.

These background documents define specific terms and provide a basis of understanding of delivery methods which is helpful when using the PDSM tools found below.

External Resources

For additional assistance, the following links are provided:

DBIA Rocky Mountain Region

DBIA National

Water Design Build Council

Facilitated Project Delivery Selection Matrix

Benefits: Provide more detail, serves as the basis for a team workshop, creates alignment amongest team members

Restrictions: Requires more knowledge to facilitate, takes more time to complete

Estimated Time: 4 hours

Documents to download: Introduction Documents and Full Project Delivery Selection Matrix

PDSM Tool PDSM Tool

Note: It is recommended to use a facilitator when performing this project delivery selection matrix. Facilitators can be contacted below:

Keith Molenaar: keith.molenaar@colorado.edu
Justin Whittaker: jwhittaker@filanc.com
Jim Mallorey: jmallorey@mwrd.dst.co.us

Abridged Project Delivery Selection Matrix

Benefits: Can be performed by one person, ideal for smaller utilities, shorter time to complete

Restrictions: Does not provide as much justification, does not create team alignment

Estimated Time: 1 hour

Document to download: Abridged Project Delivery Selection Matrix

PDSM Tool

Note: The following link provides a step-by-step video tutorial for using the Abridged PDSM:

Abridged PDSM Tutorial